Re: Doctors milk dying cancer patients for every last dollar
"I strongly disagree and suggest that he survived despite the
chemotherapy. The most important thing that he did was to quit smoking."
Wow!!!! A person has lung cancer with only 30 days to live and they
quit smoking and do nothing else and their cancer goes away? I know
personally that that isn't true.
From the responses on this thread I truly believe that most of the people who
are posting are suggesting that we have death panels and provide some sort of
alternate to chemo to anyone with cancer. Yet as I posted elsewhere in
this thread that 65% of all breast cancer patients survived for 20 years.
You know for a fact that 90% of them had chemo.
"(Reuters) - Chemotherapy helps improve breast cancer
survival in post-menopausal women, adding to a long-standing debate about how
best to treat these women, U.S. researchers said Thursday.
Fri Dec 11, 2009 12:36pm
A gene-based test called Oncotype DX made by Genomic Health Inc may help
identify a small group of women who are not likely to benefit from chemotherapy,
a second study found.
The main study proves that adding chemotherapy to treatment with the
estrogen-blocking drug tamoxifen can help prevent cancer from coming back in
women with estrogen-receptor positive breast cancers, the most common kind in
which a hormone is driving the cancer.
"We have a survival benefit that lasts for a very long time ... for
women who got both modalities of treatment versus women who just got tamoxifen,"
said Dr. Kathy Albain of Loyola University Health System in Maywood, Illinois.
She presented findings from both studies at the American Association for
Cancer Research San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium.
"It is considered a landmark study in the clinical trials literature
because it is the only one really demonstrating the survival advantage of
chemotherapy added to tamoxifen," Albain said in a telephone interview.
"Up until this trial, studies adding common chemotherapy drugs to
tamoxifen or tamoxifen alone were essentially negative."
For the study, the team followed nearly 1,500 post-menopausal women with
estrogen-receptor positive breast cancers that had spread to at least one lymph
Some of the women got both tamoxifen and a chemotherapy drug known as
anthracycline, and some got tamoxifen alone.
The team found that the women who got the chemotherapy were 24 percent
less likely to have their cancer come back.
They were also 17 percent less likely to die during the 10-year study
period, but this finding was just shy of meeting statistical significance.
The team also found that giving tamoxifen after chemotherapy ended instead of
during chemotherapy improved a woman's survival chances.
In a second study led by Albain, published in the journal Lancet Oncology,
the team evaluated whether the Oncotype DX test can predict which women would
benefit from chemotherapy.
The test examines 21 genes from a tumor sample to see how active they are,
and produces a score that predicts chemotherapy benefit. It is most commonly
used in women with estrogen-fed tumors whose cancer has not spread to a lymph
But Albain's study suggests it may also be useful in identifying women
whose tumors had spread that would not benefit from chemotherapy.
Albain said a large clinical trial is getting started that will confirm
whether the test is effective, but that will be expensive and take many years.
Meanwhile, she said, some doctors like herself plan to use the test on
certain patients to give them more choices about their breast cancer treatment
Note that this doctor, like most that I'm aware of, gives the patient the
choice regarding cancer treatment options - including no treatment.
Treatment is in the hands of the patient in every case that I'm aware of.