A person sentenced by a Royal Judge is given the maximum sentence when it's as serious as disbelief. You believe God picks only certain people before He even created them to be saved and the others are not. Instead of believing that He is all knowing and knows ahead of time who will choose Him.
How can a person then be responsible for their own action of not putting their faith in Jesus, if they believe the way you do? A person is not sentenced to death for something someone else did. (Only Jesus did that on the cross) Jesus, the Royal Judge would be the guilty party if He created you to fail. You even related one of His attributes as being a consuming fire as for burning people in hell.
God did not make you do bad...but God gave man the choice to do what is right or what is wrong. You can't be responsible and found guilty if God made you sin and be hell bound in the first place.