1. It is certainly not a slight problem.
2. "But can you grow to love somebody??" After 8 years?!! In the famous words of John McEnroe, "You cannot be serious."
3. You focus on all he has given you as far as things and lifestyle, but you don't speak of how he makes you feel, does he build you up, make you feel loved, support you emotionally? Did he ever?
4. You never said how it was in the beginning, was their passion and romance and crazy love? maybe by omitting that, you did say?
5. You didn't mention his looks, just his body. Is there a reason? Is his face attractive enough?
6. "I love the life he has allowed me to have." This sounds like you are dependent on a man for income, do you not like to work yourself or do you have no education or training?
7. "He's had his share of lumps in his life but they seem to have made him a better man instead of filling him up with resentment." Is there some hidden meaning in that we should know about?
8. "Is it possible that someone can be too good." Refer to my John McEnroe comment above.
9. "I don't want to lose him but I know he's planning an escape. And I don't blame him." This is probably the most important sentence in your whole post. Are you afraid of losing money and things. It also could be that old saying, "I don't want him, but I don't want anyone else to have him.", maybe both. Maybe you like the attention he gives you. It doesn't sound like you are afraid of being alone, sounds like you have no problem attracting men. What is the reason you two are not getting marriage counseling? If you really don't want to lose him, you will have to change and that will require getting to the bottom of your issues. You will need indivdual couseling or Dr. Phil.
10. "it was always with someone I knew I wouldn't want a long term relationship with." There is an old saying...When a guy says he never wants to get married, it means he does not want to marry you. In reversing that to your gender, I would venture to say those guys were not Mr. Right and it sounds like your current husband may not be either; Either that, or you have committment and/or intimacy issues, maybe you have them from an abusive childhood (you did not mention it). BUT, what about husband numbers 1 and 2? Did you go through all this with them, too.
11. Why are you on your 3rd marriage? What happened with the other two?
12. why can't I allow the intimacy? Um, well, for one, you say you have no attraction to him physically. That is a starting point to discuss with a professional counselor.
13. "I know this sounds trivial and can't compare to the "real" problems others on this forum have but any suggestions would be appreciated." There is perhaps a lot of significance in this sentence. My intuition says you want us to cut you a break on your strange behaviors. If that is the case, I will be honest and tell you that some of them are Sociopathic .
14. I think you need to face your fears and get a game plan, because I think he already is getting his in order. If you really feel you would act this way with any man under the same circumstances, then maybe you two should get marriage counseling. If it is just him you do not want to be with, then get some counseling for yourself, someone to figure out what you are going to do if he leaves.
15. You seem to be omitting important info here that would enable us to give you a better assessment.
If you are really sincere about saving your marriage, then I recommend this program. It fits your situation perfectly. I have used this program years ago myself and there is none better for the purpose of saving relationships. I picked the wrong person to use it on, but it still works well, just make sure if you use it that the man is deserving of your efforts. Only one person has to use the program and the other person doesn't even have to know. The changes you make will impact the relationship very positively anyway and they will respond to your new learned behaviors. It is a fun program, too. And, it is guaranteed or your money back, so you cannot go wrong.
Ellen Kreidman
I wouldn't even waste money on marriage counseling until you spend a bunch on individual counseling. But, some people cannot be helped; They are users and no matter how much others try to help them, they remain users. I hope that is not what you are, but I do have my suspicions. The very first order of business for you is to learn how to be honest with yourself, because you are severely lacking in that department. You know much more than you are leading on and you tend to blame others for your behavior (I can tell by your sentence: "He'll regret leaving..."). When you go through life that way, you have to choose your victims well, and ever so often one will stand up to you and complain. They become more of a liability to you than an asset and you end up trying to figure out how to replace them with one who is easier to manipulate and control.
"My husband has brought up my non-responsiveness many, many times. Each time he does I just think he's having a bad day and is taking it out on me"
No you don't. You think he is right, but you don't like hearing it and prefer not to deal with it.
"I must admit I don't smile much and I don't have very much fun in life."
That is the guilt trip you lay on him to make him feel bad and to enable you to keep treating him the same way.
"I just never paid much attention to intimacy. I thought sex was it."
Somehow, I do not believe that. Unless you live under a rock.
"He probably connected to me but I havn't to him."
LOL. No. He settled for what he could get from you.
"He feels like a stranger in his own home. I guess that's all the other intimacy things you are talking about."
Don't drag us into your masquerade. It is your story. You know exactly what all the intimacy things are he is complaining of better than we do.
"I don't communicate and find excuses to get out of the conversations."
When you use someone for giving you things and you know they want more than you do out of the relationship, you lose respect for them. And, you learn how to get what you want more efficiently. In other words, you give less and less of yourself while they are still giving the same. The problem you are having is that he is noticing this and reacting. So, now you want someone to tell you how to keep him and his paycheck around, without having to give him the intimacy and love he has always wanted. The old saying comes to mind...you can fool some of the people most of the time, and most of the people some of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time.
"Well, I've learned how to take care of myself with him and I'm still in pretty good shape so I don't think I'll have any trouble finding someone else. It sure was nice while it lasted. My daughter will miss him though."
You seriously need help! Are you for real?
"I'll get the Ellen Kreidman material and try that for a while."
I am not sure you will like her advice, because you have to do the things you did back when you were passionate and in love, and it doesn't sound like you ever had those moments to recreate.
"But I know the first time he sees me with someone else, or hears about me being with someone else, he'll want me back. Sorry, too late. He'll regret leaving..."
No, my guess is he will wonder why he wasted all those years.
"and you will have a stronger, more intimate relationship than ever."
Well now that's not saying much, is it.
Meaning...I have not seen her write that they ever had that kind of relationship.
narcissism:
Excessive love or admiration of oneself. A psychological condition characterized by self-preoccupation, lack of empathy, and unconscious deficits in self-esteem.
Are you sure it can be cured
Thank you, you're not so bad yourself...
Some very good points you made:
"If you think that he can't sense his level of emotional importance to you just because you've never voiced it, you're sadly mistaken."
"Life is NOT "all about me,"
"My husband and I live on a very tight budget, and we have from the beginning. However, I would much rather count pennies with him at the dining room table and laugh our heads off over one of our adventures together than sit alone in a McMansion with a Hummer in the driveway and build an empty, lonely existence for my Self."
"Perhaps, you'll meet up with MY ex, my dear! He'll wine you, dine you, tell you what a wonderful person you are and...once you've entered into that legal, binding contract of marriage, he'll burn you down and leave you in emotional, physical, sexual, financial, spiritual, and mental tatters."
They avoid those types. They are those types.
"Your daughter is watching you, closely, and you haven't taught her anything positive about being an empathetic, sympathetic, caring, loving, independent, self-sufficient human being."
I wonder, 2ss, if you've ever even experienced true, honest intimacy...intimacy does not equate sex and isn't confined to heterosexual relationships.
I'll give you three guesses and the first two don't count (as my mother always used to say when I would ask a silly question).