Well I will venture enough to say I believe God is supernatural.
I don't buy into the "weird" part. It's more of a scared thing for me. Think of how many times people were scared when they encountered some kind of God experience in the Bible.
I believe satan is the one who does things that humans feel comfortable with.
I'm kind of like Paul where he would jump in the water over his head while doing a cannon ball, and then pray, pray, pray. In the end God rewards you in a different way than you would imagine, but it's better than you imagine too. But the ride is so hard sometimes I don't know if I'll make it.