I have the same problem, which seems to have gotten worse over the years. I have always had puffy, itchy lips after eating some foods like apples, almonds, etc. Now it seems I have developed an allergy to some ingredient in lipsticks. I take a benadryl if it gets really bad. I am also huting for the cause, and friendly lipsticks. In the meantime I make my own lip balm with a double pot cooking system (just a glass jar in low boiling water) and I melt organic beeswax, coconut oil, grapeseed oil and olive oil. I let it cool and this is my lipbalm. You can play with how much beeswax you put in for softer or harder consistency. I hope this helps. And if anyone finds a good lipstick maker that is organic and non irritating please share!