Re: Sure, why do it unless you need to.

 "Again explained already above. Saponification of fats in the intestines by alkaline substances such as bile and by biding of cholesterol by dietary sterols. My question is why were you digging through your feces if you were not doing flushes at the time?"

I happened to notice the stone exit in my feces, it was very noticeable.

Just because you see something exist in your feces this does not make it a gallstone.

Now you admit that the flushes clear cholesterol and "saponified" oil from the digestive system. Congratulations you have just admitted that the flushes do in fact work.

ROTFLMAO!!!!  Yep, when all else fails twist the facts!!!  That does not prove that the so-called "liver flushes" work.  The people who do not understand the difference between the liver and the gallbladder also do not understand the difference between the cholesterol making up real gallstones and the cholesterol naturally expelled in the feces every time they have a bowel movement whether or not they are drinking oil, citrus juice and magnesium.  In fact using their philosophy we can also claim people pass gallstones through their nose.  How you say?  Well, since you want to claim expulsion of cholesterol from the body is proof the flushes expel gallstones, which is basis of the so-called  " liver flush"  claims.  So using this same basis that would mean the expulsion of any cholesterol from the body could be applied equally as a false claim these so-called "liver flushes" work.  Well, every time you blow your nose you lose epithelial cells that contain cholesterol in their membranes.  So you are actually expelling cholesterol every time you blow your nose, which you equate to the expulsion of real gallstones.  So according  to your line of thinking blowing your nose would also result in the expulsion of gallstones through the nose.  See how easy it is to twist falsehoods like you were doing?

"There is extremely compelling evidence that they don't work. Just the fact that lab testing has confirmed that these were not real Gallstones is pretty compelling. And that is just the tip of the iceberg of the evidence provided that the big blobs people are passing are not real gallstones."

Again you have just stated that in fact they do clear cholesterol from the system. Saying they don't work seems to be a ridiculous thing to say, seeing as some people are perhaps trying to clear out the cholesterol you speak of.

See my last comment to understand why your reasoning here is so ridiculous.  Just because cholesterol is expelled from the body, this does not mean you are passing gallstones.  All your statement proves is that you know NOTHING about how the body works or what gallstones really are.

Sure some may not be fully crystalline concretion formed stones, but they are made up of cholesterol, one the major substances for the bulk of gallstones.

And once again, people expel cholesterol every time they have a bowel movement, or even when they sneeze or blow their nose.  This DOES NOT mean they are passing gallstones.  Learn how the body really works and you will see what I mean.

Gallstones are known to "pass distally into other parts of the biliary tract" Therefore it is not unthinkable that they could pass down and out of the digestive tract.

Yes, gallstones can pass IF they are small enough.  What has been questioned are the claims that this big massive blobs people are passing real gallstones.  First of all they are too large to pass through the ducts even if you took a truck load of magnesium.  Secondly they have NO characteristics of real gallstones other than some of them containing cholesterol.

I've seen the people that dyed their oil and ingested it, and yes it appeared to create a dyed coating. That should be expected.

The dye experiment has been addressed previously and these experiments PROVED that these WERE NOT real gallstones.

Sorry I can't get other peoples medical records to show you that the scans didn't see the stones. That would probably be pretty interesting. But then again we wouldn't be able to see anything in the scans, so they probably would be much to look at.

I would be happy with any REAL evidence.  But despite asking over and over the pro "liver flush" people never seem to able to present any.  Not surprising though, they cannot provide what DOES NOT exist!!!

The good news though is that all these debates appear in the search engines.  So the pro "liver flush" supporters are doing an excellent job of providing the evidence that the "liver flushes" are bogus.  Keep up the good work.