Peachy...I'm looking at your husband's chart right now.
Hmm....judgements might be ruled by Sagittarius eh? and his Sagittarius Mars is squaring his Sun and Pluto! I think we've got the culprit. You look to his Mercury to get an idea of his Virgo Sun and it's in the 12th house - so this might be part of it too. It's hard to see things through the veil of the 12th house. Is his bad judgement mainly in picking friends? (11th house stuff where his Sun resides?) or....?