I'm his fiance, and I think his question may have been misinterpreted. He wasn't asking if he should water or juice fast instead of dry fasting, he was asking if he should juice fast instead of water fast. He has had some water, and after that he decided to start a juice fast (or diet or whatever you want to call it). I understand that this is a Water Fasting forum, but he was asking about BOTH a Water Fast and a juice fast, in order to determine which was better for his situation. I suppose the juice fasting forum would tell him not to talk about water fasting. Oh well.