Does anyone have any suggestion regarding long-lasting solutions or anything that may have worked for you?
If you can put on other shoes without the problem it must be something about that pair of shoes.
It has been many years ago as a teen ager that I had the same experience. I went to the store I bought them at. they exchanged them for another pair of different shoes. No reaction from them. Could be a chemical they used for the shoe color or something used on the leather.