Re: Here's TWO more documented report (stones bigger than 1cm passed from CBD) ...Re: Evidence of "giant" stones passing through common bile duct

 2 separate cases where stones in the bile duct (larger than 1 CM) passed spontaneously!

http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:tErlaJUCwoUJ:www.ncbi.nlm.nih.g...


OR

http://tinyurl.com/44a4ds4


(sorry, but I can't copy from a Google book)

And just think, if "science" (and all the other 'scientifically minded disbelievers) actually BELIEVED, then there'd likely be zillions more 'documented cases' :)

Uny

This is a great example of why people, such as the poster above, who have no idea what they are talking about should be posting on the subject.  First of all this poster keeps focusing only on the common bile duct clearly not realizing that there are other ducts involved.  This includes the cystic duct, which can cause inflammation of the gallbladder if blocked.

The poster apparently did not read the whole report or more likely did not have a clue what it said as first of all they state in both cases that the stones were lodged in the ducts, which is why they ended up hospitalized in the first place.  Again this can happen with "liver flushing" as well IF real gallstones are present.  The poster clearly did not realize either that the first patient did not have a gallbladder as it had been removed years earlier.  The second patient had their gallbladder removed BEFORE the passage of the stone.  In both cases the stones were not recovered so there is no way to tell if they broke up at all or in the second case if the surgery somehow dislodged the stone.  There is also the possibility that the lodging of the stone built up back pressure causing the stone to dislodge.  But again this is not the only duct involved and people do not always get this lucky.  Even though ending up having your gallbladder removed is not lucky per se it is still luckier than the alternatives that can happen if a stone lodges in a duct.

This is why taking advice from the LF supporters is nothing short of foolish!!!