i took this infront of a light, thats why my lips appear shiny. as i said the bottom edges are rough, it will get smooth in it's own time with the skin natural exfoliation process. I cannot rip off any skin at all it is cur...strong. It is a barrier, mobile and comfortable. I haven't put any emollient on it at all to make presentable. The top lip is fine. The bottom lip is now following, i'm pleased with the way it's healing not painful or anything. This is day 10 or 11 i think. I'm going to buy some more 2morro, incase i run out.