There would never be a case where it would. In fact, over many years this kind of policy will probably be the cause of Armageddon.
--"I want our enemies to devulge information that will protect the greater good."
Right. If our enemies are truly islamo facist as the neocon says, then how in the hell will such people ever divulge anything? They'd love nothing more than an opportunity to be tortured or killed for martyrdom.
Your position makes no sense. In fact, its right out of the neocon junior handbook. It would be refreshing to hear what you really think. Do some real self reflection on your current views. Challenge yourself. I've been where you are so I know how you think. I predict there will be a day when you'll question these ideas. Probably after many more years of its failures.