I am like you. I don't like the feeling of having foundation, powder or liquid on my facial skin. I also use MAC Bisque (brown) eyeshadow for my eyebrows and eyeliner. For mascara I use the color "maroon" by NYC because I have heard that reds near the eyes make your eyes go POP!! :P Works for me! lol. I also Almay concealer (the kind with the wand applicator) under my eyes and around my nose. For blush, I use NYC berry blush and apply it only to the apples of my cheeks. I use NYC lipstick #337A...it is a nice, natural color and for less than a buck you can't top that :)