As I posted down below, they started out the consistency of thick, brownie mix - not formed, not butt pee. I use that description as they were very dark brown in color - much darker than usual. After the third day of this the color turned significantly lighter brown and the consistency was more soupy, but still no where near butt pee, but not as thick as the brownie mix. Now, the consistency is the same, a soupy looking pile and still light brown in color. I am on day six today.
I have not seen any thick plaque or anything else for that matter. But the Oxypowder is supposed to liquify any MP. Perhaps that is why the first three day produced much more thick and dark brown bm's.