Peroxide helped me a little as well, but what really did the trick was consistent duct tape, soaking in Epsom Salts and the standard salicylic acid pads (i got the ones from Dr. Scholls). It took a lot of dedication for almost a month, but I was able to get rid of the thing for good.
I have before and after photos and more in depth description of my wart annihilation method as I like to call it at