Re:

G. You know how much I luv ya.
But I did want to give my comments on this.
And it is strictly responding to a hypothetical.
And I realize that.


"are you homeless, an outlaw, or a slave?

http://coliber.soup.io



free the market, end the state

address the need to establish a more peaceful and effective way to distribute land use grants and mineral rights

do away with banks

form councils

conscription of council members

everyone must serve at a certain age

duty of council is to decide whether people are good custodians of the property that has been entrusted to them

if not, they must give up some or all of it and relocate to a property that only requires as much care as they are capable of giving

having guns and taking a course that qualifies people to use them properly should be mandatory prior to obtaining permission to use land, as weapons are necessary to protect property from predation, both human and animal

arm everyone, eliminate jails"


-are you homeless, an outlaw, or a slave-
No. So obviously that may have an effect on my response.


-free the market, end the state-

Sounds like the words of a Revolutionary.
And unfortunately Lenin, Castro, and Mao come to mind.




-address the need to establish a more peaceful and effective way to distribute land use grants and mineral rights-

Ummm. Redistribution of wealth seems to be a popular catch phrase these days. Communists take land and "distribute" it. Mineral rights? I guess we have come into the 21st century.



-do away with banks

form councils

conscription of council members

everyone must serve at a certain age-

Ummmm. Yeah we keep coming back to the Communist and Totalitarian regime again.... And I hate seeing the word "conscription' in there.... and 'everyone must serve'..

Not sure who I would trust to form these 'councils'.

And a bank is probably necessary unless you are living in the 1700's.



-duty of council is to decide whether people are good custodians of the property that has been entrusted to them

if not, they must give up some or all of it and relocate to a property that only requires as much care as they are capable of giving-

Ummm. Sounds like Communist Russia to me.......
We will take your land..... give it to someone else...
and if you aren't worthy.... then we will give it someone else.

(And obviously I am not trusting this 'Council' very much..)



-having guns and taking a course that qualifies people to use them properly should be mandatory prior to obtaining permission to use land, as weapons are necessary to protect property from predation, both human and animal-

Ummmmm. Putting caveats on land ownership..... Ummm.
Sounds vaguely familar.......



-arm everyone, eliminate jails-

Ummmmmmm. Ummmmmmm.




G. I hope you didn't take offense.
It wasn't meant that way.

You put the post up in good faith and I do think your heart was in the right place.

But we live in complicated times.

And unfortunately - while simplicity may be the closest straw to grab - there is something to be said about 'deep' and 'levels'.

And there isn't a simplistic answer.

With much love Glax...........................
Tommy









Tweet