Well whatever his reasoning he could at least be polite enough to respond to my posts! It seems to me that any requests for help or guidance are automatically answered---email me for a tonic. His forum should not be called ask charlie about natural remedies because he does not offer free advice. His forum should be called Charlie's sales pitch.
One of my first questions to Charlie was on indigestion, he did not respond to that either, nor to my questions on nutrient rich herbs to be used like a vitamin.