Chanca Piedra vs gold coin grass 
bstar66
20 y
7,461
I've asked this question before but never got a definative answer. I've been taking Chanca Peidra for several weeks and have had two good flushes; still some moderate discomfort tho. Is Gold Coin grass any better? To you experts out there....- Unless people have taken both produc... MidlothianGirl
20 y
7,244
MoreThis is a reply to # 521,560it would be hard to give you an answer. I have taken GCG but not the other supplement, so I have no idea which is better. Sorry.
- Re: Not better just different pattione
20 y
9,381
MoreThis is a reply to # 521,560I'm not an expert but both products seem to do the job. It just depends on what you like to take. GCG breaks up the stones very well and it must help with the bile flow because it also has bupleurum in it. It is also a liquid which you have to taste and is in a grain alcohol base. (Gave me a headache.) Chanca piedra you can get in a pill form although there is liquid and dried herbs that you can make a tea out of but Chanca piedra also had some contraindication aspects like if you have hypoglycemia (which I do so I'm not taking either one.) If you read up on the chanca piedra it sounds like it does it all for the liver and any liver dieases. Both products seem to be very powerful. What moderate discomfort did the chanca piedra give you?
More
- Re: Not better just different bstar66
20 y
7,588
This is a reply to # 521,563I tried the Chanca Piedra because it is available at retail health food stores locally vs. mail order only for Gold Coin Grass. It also is cheaper at $18 a two oz bottle with no shipping charges. It has a water base and is actually pleasant tasting with a woody like taste. I haven't had any noticeable side affects except when I took it with a glass of apple juice on an empty stomache and did not eat right away. It just bothered my stomache a little but went away when I ate. The discomfort I referred to is from the upper right abb area which I hoped would dissapear after a couple of flushes. Some testamonials from others proclaimed immediate relief but I guess it will take some time.......
- Re: Not better just different Blueduck
20 y
7,503
This is a reply to # 521,566If your liver is very congested it can take some time, as you said.
Just a couple Liver Flushes is not the way to do this. We need to keep flushing until no more stones come out. When that happens, then do two or three more to make sure there are no more stones in there. After that, do maintainence flushes, a couple of times a
year, like one flush every six months.
If you are still eating the same way as you were before you start liver flushing, expect more stones....if you are eating stone forming foods, you will keep making more stones.
Blueduck- Re: Not better just different bstar66
20 y
7,446
This is a reply to # 521,573Thanks. I guess I'll stay on the Chanca Piedra and keep flushing. I am going to wait two weeks b4 the next one. I flushed 3 weeks in a row and I need a little re-coup time. The distributor for Chanca says I can go 60 drops 3x/day for two or three months without a break and for long term prevention 30 drops every other day or so....
- Re: Not better just different Blueduck
20 y
7,351
This is a reply to # 521,580Yes it is best to wait two to three weeks between flushes, so the stones have time to move down from the liver, into the gall bladder. Unless you are having gall bladder attacks or have a stone stuck. Then you can do back to back flushes, even do three in a row, each day. Other wise, wait two to three weeks between flushes.
Blueduck
- Re: Not better just different Blueduck
20 y
7,351
- Stone-forming Foods? dove003
20 y
7,457
This is a reply to # 521,573You mentioned stone-forming foods. Please give me a list of these, as I am fuzzy on these. Thanks.
- Re: Stone-forming Foods? birdog
15 y
7,587
This is a reply to # 521,763Yes, good question. I believe animal protein is one cu;prit...but what else? Don't some vegans get Gallstones too (or no)?
- Re: Stone-forming Foods Rose hips
10 y
4,972
This is a reply to # 1,379,849It's not a food, but I believe that calcium supplements contribute to gallstones. If your body doesn't absorb any of the calcium, it can travel to different places and calcify. Joints, nerves, bones..
Also, canola oil and hydrogenated oils (shortening, etc) can cause them. These oils are not digested by the body. I can only imagine the kind of havoc they wreak on the gallbladder.
- Re: Stone-forming Foods Rose hips
10 y
4,972
- Re: Stone-forming Foods? birdog
15 y
7,587
- Re: Not better just different bstar66
20 y
7,446
- Re: Not better just different Blueduck
20 y
7,503
- Re: Not better just different bstar66
20 y
7,588
- Unless people have taken both produc... MidlothianGirl
20 y
7,244
Share:
Translate This Page: