Isn't this what its all about,the results of better all around heath with these cleanses DQ?

Certainly that is what it is all about for me.  I cannot tell you what the composition of the "stones" you get from a flush may be because I truly do not know.  I have speculated that they may indeed be a essentially soap stones to a great extent; however, I have also speculated that they may form around existing smaller stones and/or debris and at any rate, appear to have a definite cleansing effect that leads to reports of better health in a huge number of people.

There are simply too many people who report benefitting from liver flushes to disregard them as useless.  Besides Andreas Moritz, noted health authority and trusted friend Jon Barron has had tremendous success with liver flushes in his annual cleansing program that thousands participate in.

My good friend, naturopathic PhD Marc Swanepoel, who developed the Sutherlandia OPC oleander supplement for use against HIV/AIDS and cancer, considers the liver flushes vitally important and specifically recommends the Andreas Moritz procedure.  As a result, I include that same procedure as a recommended part of my suggested anti-cancer protocol.

It is hard to argue with success, and both Dr. Swanepoel and myself not an approximate success rate of about 85% in stage III and IV cancers and 95% plus in stage I and II cancers (which would likely be even higher if not for damage to the immune system and major organs from prior chemo and radiation among those who first tried mainstream treatments).  Notably, while a great many cancer patients end up dying of liver failure when they go the mainstream route, such is almost unheard of for those who opt for the protocol which includes liver cleansing and other attention to keep the liver cleansed, protected and regenerated and the bile ducts open an flowing.

Thus, while will not get into the debate on exactly what the "stones" may be because I am not qualified to do anything beyond speculate, I will give my opinion that the procedure is far from being a worthless hoax and that it does provide good results for most people as far as I can tell.

DQ 

 but I can tell you that the person who did the flush reported wonderful results.

Isn't this what its all about,the results of better all around heath with these cleanses DQ? I guess the medical establishment can go on and on about the impossibilities of these cleanses and little balls of soap but the real fact is they obtain marvelous results from multitudes of people! That is success!

And yet mainstream medicine makes the same claims about chemotherapy.  So does this make chemotherapy safe or effective?

The problem is that if one aspect of the flushes is flawed then that puts the credibility of the whole thing is question.  It also puts in to question all other alternative medicines since the medical establishment is going to point out that alternatives are based on assumptions, not evidence.  So it is giving the whole alternative industry a black eye. It has been proven that the bog blobs people are passing are not real gallstones, so when people keep claiming they are it not only discredits the flushes, but again also all alternatives.

So how does passing saponified olive oil constitute "wonderful results"?

Because the person who reported it said that they experienced wonderful health improvements afterwards, and, as I have previously stated here, THAT is what matters most to me regardless of the mechanisms of the flush or what the makeup of the passed materials.