According to Andy Hall Cutler, ALA is what is necessary to lower the brain mercury.Dmsa and dmps will remove mercury from the body, however overdoing the chelation can move mercury into the brain. Cutler is against dmps injections.
Cutler:
"These chelating agents do increase symptoms a bit when taken. You need to
select a dose that doesn't create too much in the way of side effects - side
effects go up MUCH more rapidly than does the amount of mercury removed, so
there is no reason to make your kid suffer."
Cutler:
<< My doc friend told me that last year their was a bad batch of DMPS that
went
out from one pharmacy and alot of patients got sick. >>
That doesn't account for all the patients who got sick before that, after
that, and on other batches.
This is typical of the "DMPS worshipper" milieu - make excuses rather than
figure out what happened. Please don't get me wrong - they are still doing
better than the "AMA worshipping" sect which steadfastly refuses to believe
there is any problem at all. Also, since the "AMA worshippers" are
conducting an inquisition in which they attempt to burn the licenses to
practice medicine of the "DMPS worshippers" at the stake for being heretical
it is difficult for the "DMPS worshippers" to be open and honest about any
problems that may be occurring.
There have been large numbers of well documented adverse reactions to DMPS
from all sources I am aware exist, throughout the 1990's and continuing
today. The problem was not "a bad batch of DMPS." The problem is a bad
batch of doctors who don't pay attention to what happens with their patients.
Andy Cutler
Onibasu Link:
http://onibasu.com/archives/am/2458.html
So, is there ANYWHERE that I can find good info on what
each of these things does
I can give you my opinion. I am sure you can find all the conflicting
opinions you want by looking around.
DMSA (and DMPS) - chelating agents that stay OUTSIDE the brain and the body's
cells and grab up all the mercury, etc. that is available in the half or so
of your body that is not inside cells. These cause the mercury to come out
in the urine. DMPS needs to be taken about every 8 hours during treatment,
and DMSA needs to be taken about every 4. Both DMPS and DMSA are
prescription drugs. DMSA is much less expensive than DMPS. DMPS works
better than DMSA, but not enough better to justify the price in many
instances.
Alpha lipoic acid (LA) - an over the counter nutritional supplement that
chelates mercury and gets INSIDE cells and INSIDE the brain to remove mercury
that is there Lipoic acid has to be taken every 3-4 hours.
These chelating agents do increase symptoms a bit when taken. You need to
select a dose that doesn't create too much in the way of side effects - side
effects go up MUCH more rapidly than does the amount of mercury removed, so
there is no reason to make your kid suffer.
Reasonable amounts to use:
DMSA - 50-100 mg every 4 hours for several days (and nights) in a row, then
wait and repeat later.
DMPS - 50-100 mg every 8 hours for several days (and nights) in a row, then
wait and repeat later.
LA - 1/4 to 1/2 mg of LA per pound of kid every 3 hours for several days (and
nights) in a row, then wait and repeat later.
DMSA + LA - doses as above, give the DMSA with the LA every 3 hours or you
will go nuts keeping track of it, and do this for 2 or 3 days (and the
intervening nights) in a row only.
DMPS + LA - as for DMSA + LA, but give the DMPS with every second or third
dose (you choose) of LA.
Andy Cutler
Onibasu Link:
http://onibasu.com/archives/am/507.html
Is lipoic acid the only thing that will take stuff out of the brain in
your opinion?
It is the only thing known to do it safely. The old (and very nasty)
chelating agent BAL will do it. There is some rumor and innuendo that
cilantro will do it which I don't completely discount, but I wouldn't say it
is by any means proven.
Andy Cutler
Onibasu Link:
http://onibasu.com/archives/am/1670.html
Re: Just ALA chelating.and MSM comment
--- In Autism-Mercury@y..., Shari
wrote:
> Thank you very much, yes I agree, I stopped the DMSA b/c I was
seeing more negative than positive, BUT the ALA was what started his
improvement in the beginning, this weekend, he has been so attentive
again. I am looking into the corn free DMSA, but may just stay with
ALA..-Shari
A lot of adults succesfully detoxed with ALA alone (mostly because
they couldn't tolerate DMSA for some or other reason). The ALA is
essential to detox, the DMSA is not.
Andy
How do you know mercury doesn't come out of the brain easily?
There are many autopsy studies in the literature of people who worked with
mercury and then retired, or lost their job, and when they died many years
later they were found to have tons and tons of mercury still in their brains.
Assorted sources in the literature estimate the half life for mercury to
leave the brain as AT LEAST 25 years, and possibly forever.
It is also observed that the brain related symptoms (emotional symptoms,
autonomic nervous system problems and endocrine problems) do not resolve when
amalgam illness people detox using the regular protocols, and that these
problems remain with them for life (unless they do something specific to
clear the brain of mercury).
Is it really possible that you could be totally free of mercury in the body
yet still have loads of it stuffed in your brain?
Yes, and often observed, and indeed the state I was personally in for about
a year.
That seems against nature
since they body is always trying to protect the brain and achieve
equilibrium.
It is actually caused by nature.
The brain is protected by the blood-brain barrier which absolutely stops
certain toxins from passing at all, ever, no matter what. If the BBB gets
leaky and you are really really sick, it is letting maybe 0.1% of the
nasties pass - way too low to let all the mercury out.
Mercury vapor and organic mercury go into the brain, and come out again.
Inorganic mercury does not go in very easily, but really does not come out
at all.
The problem is that organic mercury such as the ethylmercury in thimerosal is
converted to inorganic mercury in the brain so it stays there forever.
Unfortunately, inorganic (mercuric) mercury does not convert back to any
form that passes the BBB.
A more technical comment about equilibrium:
The brain has a much higher affinity for mercury than the blood or the rest
of the body. Equilibrium is the condition where the rate of mercury going
into the brain and coming out of the brain is the same. Since the brain
holds on to mercury much more strongly than the body, this means that the
rate of mercury going IN from blood at concentration X is MUCH faster than
the rate of mercury coming OUT from the BRAIN at concentration X and mercury
- even inorganic mercury - concentrates in the brain slowly until it is at
dramatically higher concentrations than it is in the rest of the body. Once
this happens, the mercury stays there even if it is removed from the rest of
the body because the rate of mercury coming OUT of the brain is so slow.
So in the case of mercury, nature (in the form of your BBB) actually tries
to PREVENT equilibrium from being achieved. Since you don't live forever
this is a reasonable evolutionary adaptation as long as the BBB can keep you
far from equilibrium for your lifetime.
The real function of lipoic acid in a precise technical sense is NOT that it
somehow magically grabs the mercury and escorts it out - all it really does
is speed up the flow of mercury through the blood-brain barrier so you can
get it down into your body at some reasonable rate where it can be excreted.
Andy Cutler
Onibasu Link: http://onibasu.com/archives/am/1594.html