Actually the version of Clear Lungs that I use IS in liquid form (with alcohol). Personally I find the nebulizing to be slow going for results - I need to do it at least 3 times a day and probably over 3 days to notice any results and a week or longer to completely knock it out.
But I'm a tough case and even the strongest Antibiotics usually take a minimum of 5 to knock out. The slightly extra time with the CS is well worth it in the long run. Since I've stopped taking Antibiotics , I get my usual respiratory problems much less often. Instead of 3 or more times a year I'm down to one a year or even every other. Very worth it to be off of Antibiotics !