I guess everyone is different. I went through a bottle of this recently (also on Tony's recommendation, he referred to your results) and I noticed nothing. Maybe a little bit more nail growth from the increased minerals, but I was already taking them in another source. My hunch is that the mineral content is what makes people feel better because most of us are so deficient, though the studies they say are independent about cellular absorption certainly sound very scientifically convincing. If I could afford to, I would take another 5 or 6 bottles over a longer period of time to give it a longer test, for me it was about a month. It has a lot of stuff in it, but most at such low levels that unless the proprietary process is so special that the small amounts are truly therapeutic, I have to wonder how much it really helps unless you consume far more than the recommended dose. Still, I'm glad you had good results, and I was certainly hoping for the same. It's not unusual that I try something that lots of people like and it doesn't work for me. In fact that's usually the case. I just thought there should be another "review" on this product from someone who had a different experience.