Debate Forums are the trash cans of curezone, and I don't say that in a negative tone, because they are necessary. People used to respond to ML's posts via the acid/alkaline debate forum and no one minded. Charlie is presenting an herbal protocol for sale here on curezone and I think that this is an appropriate place to debate it - all aspects of it. I agree that this should not become a forum to strictly bash Charlie, but his theory is that all problems relate to a sluggish liver and poor bile flow and that he and only he can heal it through an herbal tonic, so in my mind anything related to those topics are fair game on this forum.