"Though companies cannot patent natural plants in their whole form, they can patent plants' individual ingredients after a long, painstaking process of breaking down the plant into its components, isolating active ingredients and then claiming to have "discovered" these natural ingredients."
They can also make a synthetic version, and often do, since those are easily patentable. Either way, neither the synthetic version nor the isolated compound are natural or likely to be compatible with our bodies, because neither are found in that form in nature. In the synthetic version, we have a substance that our bodies have not naturally adapted to or encountered. In the isolated compound form, we have a single compound instead of the compound together with all the synergistic components found in the natural plant - which is how we encounter it in nature.
Nature works synergistically, just like the human body itself, where the total organism is much greater than the sum of the parts. Remove one key supporting compound and you have changed the effectiveness and compatibility of the entire substance. Similarly, a deficiency in one vital nutrient among a great many can cause other nutrients to be less effectively utilized in the human body, just as an impairment in one organ or system in the body can cause impairments in others and lead to poor overall health for the entire body.
Big Pharma's scientists either fail to realize that, or else don't care because only the unnatural synthetics and isolates are patentable and profitable. Which is no doubt why over 95% of all FDA approved drugs have side effects. And which fits right in with the great failing of mainstream medicine itself - treating the body as a collection of parts and only treating the part where a symptom manifests itself instead of treating the underlying causes and the whole body.
When man plays God, or when profit becomes God, mankind invariably suffers.
DQ
I am not sure that I understand your question. Are you asking if a drug manufacturer or some agent of Big Pharma could claim contamination because similar compounds are found in a natural supplement to the synthetic or isolated compounds in the patented approved version, of course they could and would do it at the drop of a hat. Never mind that nature and the natural version of the compound was there first. All that matters is profits and no deed is too foul to protect their profits and marketplace, regardless of the cost to humanity.
One has but to look at how the FDA allows drugs to stay on the markets long after they are identified as proven killers. No better example can be found than how long it took to pull Vioxx and what is happening now with Avandia and Fosamax. The FDA's primary function is to insure profits and suppress competition for those they really serve - the corrupt World Pharma empire. Any beneficial actions on behalf of humanity are far too often either coincidental, cosmetic or as a result of exposure and public pressure that finally becomes too great to resist.
You know, when I write about the evils and failings of agencies, industries and mainstream medicine, I am really not condemning the rank and file workers in the FDA and other agencies, many of whom sincerly believe they are protecting the public, just as I am not condemning the hundreds of thousands of dedicated, caring and hard working doctors and medical professionals. It is those who mislead them and guide them that are corrupt. And it is those who have bought the souls of the misleaders who are beyond corrupt. They are truly evil.
Sadly, most people, including those in the FDA and other agencies and in the medical professions, are not even aware that such evil people exist, much less that they are being used as tools to control our lives and our health.
DQ (also a Tony)
Dang, only several hundred to go and they might approach all the FDA approved drugs that have been recalled. Of course, natural supplements have no chance of every achieving even a tiny fraction of all the DEATHS caused by the approved drugs.
Once again we have the laughable spectacle of the FDA pulling or warning about a supplement because it is contaminated by dangerous medicines from drugs the FDA has approved.
And, as was so ably reported by fellow CureZone health advocate grzbear, it is quite possible that the source of the "similar" substances being found in many so-called contaminated supplements is actually the natural plant that the Big Pharma guys adulterated into a patentable form that could reap huge profits but was not naturally compatible with the human body.
The bottom line: further scurillous attempts to limit our access to natural herbal products under the guise of public safety to mask the real purpose of casting doubts on supplements in general and eliminating competition for their true lords and masters.
If the FDA, or some posters here on CureZone, gave a tinkers damn about our health and safety, then they would look at the 120,000 deaths each year caused by properly prescribed FDA approved medicine, instead of concentrating so much effort and propaganda on natural supplements.
If each approved drug death, side-effect or recall were treated with as much publicity and concern as the tiny handful among natural supplements, the products of Big Pharma would be almost non-existent. And the world would be a much safer and healthier place.
Keep serving 'em up. Everybody on the home team wants a chance at bat when you are on the mound.
DQ