This table summarizes available western data regarding breath holding times for people with various health states. Note that the first study was conducted almost a century ago.
Types of people investigated |
Number of subjects |
Breath holding time, seconds |
|
Fit instructors |
22 |
46 s |
Flack, 1919 |
Home defence pilots |
24 |
49 s |
|
British candidates |
23 |
47 s |
|
US candidates |
7 |
45 s |
|
Delivery and test pilots |
27 |
39 s |
|
Pilots training for scouts |
15 |
42 s |
|
Pilots taken off flying through stress |
|
34 s |
|
Normal subjects |
30 |
23 s |
Friedman, 1945 |
Neurocirculatory asthenia |
54 |
16 s |
|
Normal subjects |
22 |
33 s |
Mirsky et al, 1946 |
Anxiety states |
62 |
20 s |
|
Normals and class 1 heart patients |
16 |
16 s |
Kohn & Cutcher, 1970 |
Class 2 and 3 heart patients |
53 |
13 s |
|
Pulmonary emphysema |
3 |
8 s |
|
Functional heart disease |
13 |
5 s |
|
Normal subjects |
6 |
28 s |
Davidson et al, 1974 |
Asymptomatic asthmatics |
7 |
20 s |
|
Asthmatics with symptoms |
13 |
11 s |
Perez-Padilla et al, 1989 |
Normal subjects |
14 |
25 s |
Zandbergen et al, 1992 |
Panic attack |
14 |
11 s |
|
Anxiety disorders |
14 |
16 s |
|
Outpatients |
25 |
17 s |
Gay et al, 1994 |
Inpatients |
25 |
10 s |
|
COPD or CHF (congenital heart failure) |
7 |
8 s |
|
12 heavy smokers |
12 |
8 s |
|
Normal subjects |
26 |
21 s |
Asmudson & Stein, 1994 |
Panic disorder |
23 |
16 s |
|
Normal subjects |
30 |
36 s |
Taskar et al, 1995 |
Obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome |
30 |
20 s |
|
Normal subjects |
76 |
25 s |
McNally & Eke, 1996 |
Normal subjects |
10 |
38 s |
Flume et al, 1996 |
Successful lung transplantation |
9 |
23 s |
|
Successful heart transplantation |
8 |
28 s |
|
Normal subjects |
31 |
29 s |
Marks et al, 1997 |
Outpatients with COPD |
87 |
8 s |
Sit down and rest for 5-7 minutes. Completely relax all your muscles, including the breathing muscles. This relaxation produces natural spontaneous exhalation (breathing out). Pinch your nose closed at the end of this exhalation and count your BHT (breath holding time) in seconds. Keep nose pinched until you experience the first desire to breathe. Practice shows that this first desire appears together with an involuntary push of the diaphragm or swallowing movement in the throat. (Your body warns you, “Enough!”) If you release the nose and start breathing at this time, you can resume your usual breathing pattern (in the same way as you were breathing prior to the test).
Do not extend breath holding too long. You should not gasp for air or open your mouth when you release your nose. The test should be easy and not cause you any stress. The BHT test does not interfere with your breathing.
[Warning. Some, not all, people with heart disease, migraine headaches, and panic attacks may experience negative symptoms minutes later after this light version of the test. If this happens, they should avoid this test.]
Some western doctors call such a BHT test “a period of no respiratory sensations” because when the time is voluntarily extended there is a stress that increases with each further second of breath holding.