I'm with you on this one. My only concern is to have posts appear in their proper place. I think P Tree made som very valid points here. If we need to create more places, let's do so. But I think we should be expanding rather than contracting. We have accomodated every reasonable poster on this site. I say we keep doing so. We even have a place for spammers and detractors. This is small potatos in comparison.
Let's not blow it out of porportion. If we think constructively we can solve this very easily.
I think a testimonials forum solves this particular situation.
What is the purpose of a debate forum?
Would not tetemonials be better suited in a forum specially created for that purpose?