"......It's a long story
and beyond the technicality of this group why this is actually so..........."
One phrase that sums up the entire response.
Amateur self appointed experts with no real knowledge or engineering skills to back their views.
Bob Beck spent a lot of time and money researching these protocols and Russ Torlage from Sota has carried on this work. The devices have been in wide use for over 10 years, and Beck has been vindicated time and time again.
The so called 5k Oscillating Pulser has no track record over time. No-0ne to my knowledge has done any direct comparisons, certainly nothing to justify the black and white assertions expressed by BG. But then ignorance breeds black and white views.