I think you will like all three products. I had never heard of ChopSaver, but after reading about it, it does sound like a very nice lip balm IF you get the "Original" forumla. Very nice ingredients, including some very healing herbal extracts.
I would not recommend the "ChopSaver Gold" as it contains chemical sunscreen, and many people are sensitive to those rather harsh ingredients, especially on their lips.
If the ChopSaver feels too stiff to apply easily, just hold the tube in your closed hand for a few minutes, and it should soften up a little. If that doesn't work, then apply it to your finger, and from there to your lips. It is likely the carnauba wax that is making it stiff to apply.
Ingredients for ChopSaver Original:
Castor Oil, Candelilla Wax, White Beeswax, Shea Butter, Mango Butter, Aloe Vera, Carnauba Wax, Avocado Oil, Apricot Kernel Oil, Grapeseed Oil, Extracts of Arnica, Extracts of Calendula, Extracts of Comfrey, Extracts of Raspberry, Extracts of White Willow, Vitamin E, Citrus Essential Oils.
Ingredients for ChopSaver Gold (SPF 15)
The ChopSaver Gold with SPF15 contains the same natural ingredients but with added active ingredients of 7.2% Octinoxate and 4.3% Oxybenzone.