Re: Proof that these ARE gallstones.

 "The claims of 100's or 1000's of "stones" being released are just plain false. It is not physically possible for the liver or gallbladder to contain 100's or 1000's of stones, particularly of the size that people are reporting, being expelled in their faeces. When a person knows how the body works, and knows anatomy, they can see how utterly ridiculous these claims are."

.. and I'm sorry, but this is just plain false. OF COURSE the liver and gall bladder can contain the amount of stones that I passed. You need to go back to biology class take a look at how big the liver actually is. It averages about 3lbs in a normal adult and is about the size of an American football... these organs contain more than enough room for the stones that people are passing. Get your facts straight!

First of all liver stones are EXTREMELY rare except in a few countries.  So even if these were real stones they would unlikely have originated from the liver.

Secondly,  the half inch stones you mentioned would have taken up most of the space in the gallbladder not leaving enough room for thousands of stones.  

And if you learned biology then you would have known that the liver may be the size and weight but most of that is solid tissue and thus cannot harbor stones in those areas.

If you ever give me that description of the "stones" you passed I keep asking for we can probably settle this really quick.