"Next problem is that I am a complete carb addict. Sugar is manageable, but carbs are not manageable for me."
If you are a pre-diabetic - carbs will kill you, literally. It's a matter of managing your carbs or dying young - it's that serious. An a1c of 6.9 is not good and your doctor is right.
I've been Type II for about ten years. My diabetes clinic's guidelines are no more than fifteen carbohydrates per meal. It's difficult to maintain, but I stick with it most of the time and I've never had to take meds. In fact, my last a1c was 5.5 - which is within the normal range.
I even try to use Dr. Bernstein's diet of three carbohydrates per meal and have been able to do that for weeks at a time. Bernstein is a Type I diabetic who is now in his 70s and has lived that long because of his dedication to his diet which is outlined in his book "Dr. Bernstein's Diabetes Solution: The Complete Guide to Achieving Normal Blood Sugars." You can find the book and reviews at this site:
http://www.amazon.com/Dr-Bernsteins-Diabetes-Solution-Achieving/dp/0316182699...
There are two things that I've found that help me control my blood sugar besides the strict diet and that is a product called Cunsulin, and massive amounts of fish oil. I take 2,000 mg of fish oil per day. Not flax oil which has Omega 6 that is bad for you but fish oil which doesn't have Omega 6 - only Omega 3.
Also - just for your own information, get a glucose blood test monitor and test two hours after eating from time to time. These monitors and test strips are very inexpensive and you will be able to see for yourself whether or not you are eating healthy.
Fat causing Type II is utter bull shit.
I test quite often. I know what raises my blood sugar. Two slices of bread raises it to 240 which is more than ice cream which takes it to 160. White potatoes, rice - white or brown, takes my blood sugar to 360. Bacon or eggs cooked in loads of butter (ummh) raises my blood sugar to 85 after two hours. By controlling my diet I control my Type II.
You mentioned in your OP that you don't feel any different. That's true. That's why 50% of all diabetics have not been diagnosed.
Why do I still have Type II after 10 years? Because it is irreversible and anyone who says that it is, is a liar and is probably out to get you to spend some money for their charlatan cures.
The thing about Type II is that it's completely in your hands. The doctor can advise you what to do, but it's all up to you as an individual. You can control your a1c - if your want to, but it's up to you.
I recommend that you read the book "Dr. Bernstein's Diabetes Solution: The Complete Guide to Achieving Normal Blood Sugars" that was listed earlier. Bernstein was an engineer who couldn't even in those days purchase a blood sugar monitor and had to get one from his wife who was a doctor. Then after tracking his blood sugar for months and determining what causes blood sugar elevation he took it to the medical community who didn't pay any attention to him. Finally at age 43 he entered medical school and became a physician where they finally began to listen. His diet includes unlimited amounts of fat. He and he alone is the reason that anyone can test their own blood sugar at home. This is exactly what my clinic in Seattle has found and what they practice and they have been researching diabetes since 1923.
Like so many charlatans your link is selling their untested and never reviewed by science, complete bull shit regarding diabetes and is not only dangerous but death to the diabetic user who goes that direction.
Where is their science reviewed and tested diabetic free users?
Anyone who doesn't get a blood sugar testing meter to check their own blood sugar on a regular basis is denying the causes of their diabetes. I have gone the route that your link is going and going raw and juicing in particular is suicide for diabetics.
How has that link done for your diabetes? Or is it that you don't have diabetes but you know how everyone else should live?
More twisting of reality.
That link suggests that to be true from a singular, non reviewed "test." There is no other recognized research comes to that conclusion. Also, what you didn't note is that the unreviewed study indicates that a low calorie diet resulting in weight loss may reduce diabetes symptoms. It has no conclusions and has not been reviewed
First you post a BS link that is selling their "diet" plan for diabetes. If it's so great why are the selling things? Are you diabetic? Who do you know personally who has benefited from either of these approaches?
I eat loads of fat. My BMI is 24.6. From my clinical tests of last week:
Cholesterol level 119
Triglyceride 47
HDL (good fat) 44
LDL (bad fat) 58
Blood Glucose Level 86
By the way - I was diagnosed with prostate cancer from a lab test, 20 years ago and refused surgery and my PSA a week ago was: .61
The proof is in the lab results.
I've been researching/looking for a diabetes diet for more than ten years because I have Type II diabetes. My Virginia Mason diabetes clinic is internationally recognized as one of the top diabetic clinics in the United States. I was initially taught by them to follow a low carb diet and by following their 15 carbohydrate per meal recommendations I have been able to control my diabetes for all those ten years without medication of any kind! All their patients are given this same diet and I have watched their blood sugar levels make dramatic drops and have also watched them lose a great deal of weight in the process.
You HAVE NOT presented any legitimate diabetic information. McDougal claims to 'cure' diabetes but having followed his diet along with my wife for support for an entire year I found it to exacerbate my pre-diabetic conditions. You then suggest raw foods and juicing which I also tried for a while which gave me horrible blood sugar values and is of not benefit at all. And you call me "closed minded?" My recommendations come with years and years of personal experience.
I've done everything that you have suggested and all it has brought me is a much worse form of diabetes. You have presented nothing, absolutely nothing to even suggest that your ideas even work. You have never responded to the question as to whether on not you are diabetic so I can only assume that you aren't because you have presented nothing that works for you. You are just like many others who think that they have "valuable information" who go out and tell everyone else what to do when you've never ever experienced your suggestions your self.
You made no comments on my blood tests which by any standards are fantastic for anyone, let alone an 81 year old diabetic.
Here's just a little information on low carb diets and the top two aren't really very low carb.
http://www.livestrong.com/article/401698-low-carb-diets-for-type-2-diabetes/
Type 2 diabetes can be explained as a carbohydrate intolerance. Your body is not able to deal with the carbohydrates you eat, which result in high blood sugar levels that can eventually lead to health complications in the long-term. Lowering your carb intake can help your blood sugar levels stay within the recommended parameters. A study investigated the effect of a low-carb diet, providing less than 20 g of carbohydrates a day, for 16 weeks in participants with type 2 diabetes. This low-carb diet helped type 2 diabetics reduce their A1C levels, which corresponds to the average blood sugar levels over the last 3 months, from 7.5 percent down to 6.3 percent, as published in December 2005 in "Nutrition & Metabolism." The American Diabetes Association recommends that people with diabetes keep their A1C below 7 percent.
In the study published in "Nutrition & Metabolism" in December 2005, type 2 diabetics following a low-carb diet for 16 weeks lost a significant amount of weight, from an average of 289.7 lbs. down to 270.5 lbs., which corresponds to 6.6 percent of their initial body weight. In addition to helping you lose weight, eating low-carb could also help you optimize your blood lipid profile. In this same study, their triglycerides decreased by 42 percent, from a baseline level of 236.0 mg/dL down to 137.7 mg/dL.
http://www.livestrong.com/article/370258-low-carbohydrate-diet-for-diabetic-t...
Type 2 diabetes can be defined as a disease of carbohydrate intolerance, according to the Metabolism Society, and this is why eating carbohydrates result in harmfully high blood sugar levels. However, the American Diabetes Association still recommends that people with diabetes get between 45 and 60 g of carbohydrate at each meal and 15 to 30 g of carbohydrate for a snack, which corresponds to about 45 percent to 65 percent of their daily calorie intake. Many people with type 2 diabetes decide to try the low-carb approach instead and find their blood sugar levels significantly improved as a result.
Since type 2 diabetes is characterized by a carbohydrate intolerance, it appears logical that lowering your carbohydrate intake will help your blood sugar levels stay within the desirable range. A 16-week study showed that a group of 28 overweight patients with type 2 diabetes following a low-carb diet, which provided less than 20 g of carbohydrates a day, reduced their hemoglobin A1C by 16 percent, from a baseline level of 7.5 percent down to 6.3 percent at the end of the study, as reported in December 2005 of "Nutrition & Metabolism." Hemoglobin A1C reflects your average blood sugar levels over a 3-month period and a value below 7.0 percent is desirable. Another longer term study showed that type 2 diabetics eating a low-carb diet that provided about 80 to 90 g of carbohydrates a day, were able to bring their A1C from a baseline level of 8.0 percent down to 6.9 percent after a year, according to the results published in May 2008 of "Nutrition & Metabolism." A long-term follow-up done with the same participants showed that following the low-carb diet had helped them to keep their A1C within target, with an A1C value of 6.8 percent at 44 months.
The other beneficial side effect of following a low-carb diet to improve your diabetes control is weight loss, and especially fat loss. The long-term 44-month follow-up study published in May 2008 in "Nutrition & Metabolism" showed that following a low-carb diet, with an intake of 80 to 90 g of carbohydrates a day, helped participants drop a significant amount of weight. Their weight loss averaged 16.6 lb., from a baseline body weight of 221.8 lb. down to 205.2 lb. Participants lost most of their excess weight in the first six months, but were later able to maintain their weight at a lower point even after 44 months.
By the way, if you research The American Diabetes Association diabetes diet you will find that it gives you diabetes.
http://lowcarbdiets.about.com/od/bernsteinsdiabetesdiet/p/bernsteinintro.htm
Bernstein's Diabetes Diet : Overview
By Laura Dolson, About.com Guide
Updated February 18, 2008